Cost: Don't exactly remember, either 10¢ or 25¢
Got this at a pawn shop's going-out-of-business sale, hence the cheap price. Christian artists doing covers, including a couple of white metal bands. Not being familiar with some of the songs, I tried to give the originals I didn't know a brief sampling, which generally wasn't a great idea.
1. Tourniquet - Dogman (King's X)
Don't like the original or the cover either, for that matter. They did succeed in making the main riff much heavier (the guitars are tuned even lower than the original), but that's about it.
2. Doug Pinnick - I Will Follow (U2)
King's X guy. U2. Zzz.
3. Echo Hollow - Sunday Bloody Sunday (U2)
Guy Ritter and Gary Lenaire's post-Tourniquet band. Haven't heard anything else of the band but they're supposed to play metal. This is not a metal version. I'm no U2 fan, and this pales in comparison to the original.
4. Spy Glass Blue - Song To My Parents (Keith Green)
I had never heard any of Keith Green's actual music before, I just knew him as late-'70s-bearded-Christian-music-guy-who-died-in-a-plane-crash. The cover translates the piano melody of the original to electric guitar pretty well.
5. Reflescent Tide - Hold Me Jesus (Rich Mullins)
Well then.
6. Justin Fox - Do It For Love (The 77's)
Moving on now.
7. Paul Roraback - 2112 Overture (Rush)
Feels like it's missing a little something that can only come from the '70s. Still excellent, though. Best track on here.
8. Crimson Thorn - Loud 'N' Clear (Stryper)
In all seriousness, The Yellow and Black Attack EP has some great songs despite the lyrics. I can even see how "Loud 'N' Clear" could have potential done in a more extreme manner, as thrash or death metal. But this is just too unenergetic and cheap sounding for a serious cover. It sort of works as a funny cover--I have to admit I laughed a little bit when the, uh, guitar solo started.
9. Guardian - C'mon Rock (Stryper)
Not terrible, but nowhere near the original. Always thought it was odd these guys chose to cover the entire Stryper EP well after they had moved on from playing anything remotely metal.
10. The Channelsurfers - God Is Bigger (from Veggie Tales)
I found this interesting as a cover, but not as a song itself. Very telling that a cover of a Christian kid's show song about how one shouldn't be afraid of monsters isn't the worst tune on the album.
11. Blackball - Message In A Bottle (The Police)
Decent attempt even though it kind of falls apart at the choruses. Great bassline, and even though he doesn't sound too much like him, the singer nails Sting's cadence.
12. Atomic Opera - Water Grave (The Imperials)
I used to think these guys had released a metal album...I think I was mixing up their band name with Barren Cross' Atomic Arena album in my head. Anyway, they do "Water Grave" as a somber acoustic number, very Collective Soul sounding. Interesting take on it, though I like the Imperials version better.
13. One Bad Pig - Cosmic Cowboy (Barry McGuire)
Prior to this the only Barry McGuire song I knew was his most famous, the definitive version of the '60s protest song "Eve of Destruction." The original "Cosmic Cowboy" is very weird, with almost spoken-word main vocals. The cover unfortunately takes a more rocking approach--it loses a lot of the odd charm of the original, which the nice guitar solos don't make up for.
14. The Violet Burning - It's All Too Much (The Beatles)
In contrast to the previous song, this one actually captures the weirdness of the original quite well, albeit with inferior vocals.
15. Larry Norman - Jesus Freak (DC Talk)
...That should wrap up this post.