Cost: $3.00
Threw this in with an online order as a cheapo add-on. It was listed as "stoner metal." Uh, okay...
Initially, I was mentally classifying this as some kind of strange mellow groove metal during the first two tracks, although I think overall it's most accurate to call it some kind of hard alternative or alternative metal. I realize that label itself doesn't really mean much. One track has a saxophone part--they're that kind of band. The riffing is very groovy and bouncy, but most of it isn't particularly hard-hitting music, and with no real aggro vocals, someone expecting Pantera/Machine Head type stuff would probably be disappointed. And yes, while they are instances where the guitar tone and a groovy riff might be reminiscent of some sort of stoner metal, as a whole I suspect this would be very disappointing for someone looking for the standard sounds of that genre.
Most of this feels very unfocused, with odd musical tangents that feel silly, and not in an amusingly off the wall way as in something like Scatterbrain. I will say to their credit, despite the year of release and one member's Rage Against the Machine shirt, this avoids most nu pitfalls aside from some overly bouncy riffs that are thankfully uncommon. The vocalist has a heavily accented, somewhat warbly default, but also seems fond of experimenting with various vocal histrionics (he even occasionally belts out some deep vox which remind me of Chuck Billy's guttural stuff from '80s/'90s Testament!) and using effects/distortion (sometimes this vaguely reminds me of Death SS, oddly). I wouldn't classify the singing itself as crappy per se, but the vocal style doesn't lend itself to me taking Dirty Lust seriously at all.
Highlights are few. "The Century of Superstition" is an actual foray into doomy/stoner fare, and while it stands out positively among the other material here, it's not terribly impressive either. There's an extremely brief "brutal" section in "I Saw And Angel Last Night" [sic] and some cacophonous stuff at the very end of the album which make me think the musicians would do a capable job in an actual death or grind band.
Based on where I bought this, I think it's safe to assume the "stoner metal" tag was just a quick, lazy descriptor rather than any sort of malicious deceit. But it's a lot more appealing and marketable calling this that than whatever it actually is. It certainly worked on me!